How do we introduce and standardise a global Integrated Business Planning Process?
Need to expand focus and integration of new, growing, strategic market.
Focus on Innovation and Technology and global process step integration.
Challenges:
The monthly IBP process had traditionally been driven by demand from the Americas and did not include EMEA or Asia-Pacific demand
There was ineffective integration of data from a new and developing global market. This led to poor forecasting of customer demand, raw materials, capacity, and labour, as well as reactivity and fire-fighting, opposed to proactivity
Coupled with poor data integration, the business IBP cycle had become routine, “data heavy” and suffered from team members “going through the motions”
The initial IBP process was more than 15 years old, and data complexity, accuracy and integrity had degraded over time
The traditional, base business dominated the process. Stronger integration of the new growing market needed to be undertaken to facilitate strategic execution
Strategic growth in a new global market would challenge global capacity. An upgraded IBP process was critical to forecast when investment was needed to deliver increased capacity; especially with commissioning lead times of 12-18 months
The Approach:
Assembled a design team with leaders of each process step within the IBP process
Comprehensive evaluation of current state – Process, Data, Organisation, Inputs/Outputs
Education related to the evolution of S&OP into IBP and the importance of scenario planning
Analysis of data inputs and outputs to evaluate if data complexity could be reduced Innovation, Project Mgr. and Portfolio Mgt.? Where to meet the customer? Planning materials for demand forecasts? Strategic Material Supply? Inventory Planning? Financial Forecasting?
Process mapping for current state and future state and identification of process change using IDEF0 and Kaizen principles
Requirement to build standardised process – data, people, process steps and presentations
The Achievements
Complete process redesign which included standardised process, input and output templates, RACI associated with each process step and significantly reduced cycle process time
An IBP process which acted as a conduit between short- and long–term horizons
An upgraded process that provided better focus and integration of an important market that will drive strategic growth
Improved Product Management Review process that was now capable of managing NPD through to product launch and understanding its impact on market share and portfolio management
Enhanced integration to deliver capacity scenarios and investment requirements that were driven by global market growth and market share expansion forecasts
An IBP process cycle that was reduced from 28 days to 5 days which had a significant impact on process data integrity
A focus of “Learn by doing” understanding that forecast data is inherently lacking in accuracy, but the team would constantly strive for data accuracy improvements
The Ask:
How do we identify & introduce a single ERP system globally and single source of truth?
How do we engage the entire organisation to focus on a single objective?
How do we project manage something of this scale and complexity?
Challenges:
7 ERP instances across a global organisation, inherited through acquisition or developed by standalone divisions, to be replaced by one fully integrated global SAP Solution
Significant inconsistencies in Processes, covering Manufacturing, Operations, Finance and Supply Chain with no global QMS and regional variation to policies and procedures that were inconsistent with corporate policies
No project management experience of managing something on this scale
The approach must be standardised across all sites – Complex program governance
Overloaded internal staff – essential to engage all functions to achieve success
The Approach:
Establishment of a Centre of Excellence (COE) aligned with PMO that:
Selected and Implemented an Enterprise Process Management Tool
Developed / Approved processes with geographical variations
Included Data Cleansing and Process Prioritisations across all functions
Ensured Quality Management System was aligned to processes and SSoT
Enabled Knowledge Transfer with permanent FTEs in COE, aligned with PMO
Global Program Specific PMO
Design and implement the required program governance – Standardised Toolkit
Setup, chartered, and launched 7 global workstreams
The Achievements
Single source of truth (SSoT) established
Global data management policies and procedures developed and implemented
Utilising off the shelf system solutions where feasible
Savings in excess of $500m
Stable implementation of the selected ERP system across all functions
Global governance structure and communication plan implemented
Centre of Excellence knowledge sharing reduced planning / implementation phase
Graphical toolkit utilised to facilitate remote and group collaboration
Program reporting cadence developed from C-Suite down
18 functions across the organisation engaged and successfully participated
Background
The Paper Mill
The paper mills convert wood chips or recycled paper into pulp, utilizing mechanical and chemical pulping. The pulp may be bleached to remove impurities and achieve the desired brightness and color of the final paper product before being processed into slurry which is then spread onto a moving wire mesh belt, where water drains away and the fibers begin to bond together to form a huge sheet of paper. When I say huge, it is at least 2 metres wide moving through presses to remove more water and to compress the fibers together to increase the paper’s strength and density.The pressed paper sheet is then dried using heated rollers or drying cylinders to remove remaining moisture. In some cases, paper may then be coated with materials such as clay or other chemicals to improve its print quality and brightness.At the final stage of the process, the paper is rolled up to form massive 2-metre-wide, 200-metre-long rolls which are shipped to the substrate manufacturer.
The Substrate Manufacturer
The substrate manufacturer in this case study produced substrates to be used as adhesive labels. The process started usually with a 2-metre-wide, 200-metre-long roll of backing paper which is fed through a coating machine where silicon is sprayed onto one side of the backing paper and controlled to thicknesses measured in microns.At the other end of the process line a 2-metre-wide, 200-metre-long roll of surface paper is fed through the same coating machine and has adhesive sprayed onto one side of the surface paper and controlled to thicknesses also measured in microns.The two rolls are brought together in the middle into one single 2-metre-wide, 200-metre-long roll with the adhesive surface in contact with the silicon surface and the two paper surfaces on the outside of the sandwich.Often the rolls are slit into smaller rolls before being distributed or sent to a specialized slitting company for narrow dimension rolls.
The Slitting Company
The slitting company performs additional processes such as cutting, slitting, rewinding, or packaging before being sent out to customers, typically printers.
The Printer
Here starts an unusual tri-partite supply chain relationship between the retailer, the food packer and the printer.The retailer often provides the design inputs for a label to ensure that the label includes all required information such as the retailer’s brand, product name, ingredients, nutritional information, allergen information, barcode, expiration date, plus any other mandatory labeling requirements as per food regulations, and the labels must be both attractive and compliant with industry standards.The printer will compile the required data from the retailer and the food packer, complete the design of the label then print and despatch the labels to the food packer. Sometimes the retailer may use its own graphic designer and provide the finished design to the printer. The food packer buys the labels from the printer, applies them to the packed product and distributes them to the retailer.The label material suitable for food packaging, must have properties such as moisture resistance, and durability, and must be FDA compliant. Common label materials for food packaging include coated paper, synthetic materials like polypropylene or vinyl, and eco-friendly options like compostable or biodegradable labels.The inks must be food-safe, FDA-compliant, resistant to moisture, oils, and other environmental factors to maintain label quality and readability.The printing method must suit the label design and quantity requirements. Common printing methods for food packaging labels include:
Digital Printing: Ideal for short print runs and variable data printing;
Flexographic Printing: Suitable for large volume printing and offers high-speed production; and
Offset Printing: Provides high-quality printing for intricate designs but is more suitable for longer print runs. After printing, finishing touches may be added to the labels such as laminating, varnishing, or applying protective coatings to enhance durability and moisture resistance.
This step can help protect the labels from smudging, fading, or damage during handling and storage.The printer must store the printed labels in a clean, dry environment to prevent damage or contamination.
The Food Packer
In this case study, the food packer prepares short shelf-life, chilled, cooked meat products where its customers, the retailers, would place orders on a daily basis for next day delivery.The food packer maintains processes and procedures which pay careful attention to hygiene, temperature control, and packaging materials to ensure the safety and quality of the food.A critical activity is portion control of the chilled food products into the appropriate serving sizes or quantities for packaging. Calibrated equipment is employed to ensure accurate portioning avoiding overfilling or underfilling.The packs are securely sealed to prevent contamination and maintain freshness and labels are applied using appropriate labeling equipment to ensure accurate placement and adhesion.Once the chilled food products are packed and sealed, they are placed into appropriate shipping containers or insulated boxes for refrigerated, temperature-controlled transportation to the retailers’ distribution depots.
The Retailer
Retailers selling chilled cooked meat products face various challenges that can impact product safety, quality, and customer satisfaction. However, their main challenge is the Customer Experience. Providing a positive customer experience is essential for building brand loyalty and attracting repeat business. But how does the retailer balance product freshness, value for money and availability with optimal stock levels?Maintaining optimal stock levels is important to ensure that customers have access to the products they want when they want them. Therefore, retailers need to strike this critical balance between having enough stock to meet demand without overstocking and risking product spoilage or wastage.
The Consumer
When making purchasing decisions, consumers are increasingly looking for value for money which retailers can provide by offering value through competitive pricing, promotions, bundle deals, loyalty programs, and quality products that justify the price. However, the consumer also expects the products to be safe, high quality, convenient to use with clear information on ingredients and cooking instructions (if applicable) and to be readily available when they want to buy. Upward trending demands are friendly customer service and efficient checkout processes.
The Ask:
The project started at the printer with an analysis of its performance against its customer service promise. The printer promised 95% guaranteed next day delivery but was actually only achieving less than 50%. The printer wanted to increase its customer service performance whilst reducing its replenishment lead times without increasing stock. Ensuring that the printer could achieve these objectives involved other stakeholders in the supply chain.
One of the challenges is that downstream to, and including, the printer, big batch manufacturing drives the supply chain. At the consumer end of the supply chain, chilled meats are purchased in packs of ones or twos. How do we manage this funnel? What kind of controls can we put in place?
Objectives
Increase customer service performance;
Reduce replenishment lead times; and
Decrease stock holding.
The Approach
First a detailed analysis was conducted:
Analysis of sales ledger data to determine current COTD or OTIF performance level;
Analysis of sales ledger data to determine Customer Demand Time;
Analysis of SKU data to determine minimum and maximum stock levels;
Replenishment lead times per SKU;
Usage rates per SKU.
The output from the analysis was used to build a mathematical model of the process a product family of label types. A solution was designed and verified. The solution was implemented as a pilot was conducted on the selected product family of label types. This was then rolled out across all of the other products.
This approach was shared with the slitting company and the meat packer on a pilot basis. At this point, the driver was the retailer’s daily order quantities.
The meatpacker’s labelling stock was monitored by the printer. When the meatpacker fulfilled the daily orders to the retailer, the label stock that was used was replenished by the printer. The printer would then order the exact replacement substrate required for next day label delivery from the slitting company who made twice daily deliveries into the printer from a local warehouse.
This model was then extended to the substrate manufacturer to replenish stock at the slitting company.
The delivery schedules were transformed to have the last delivery loaded onto the delivery vehicle first and the first delivery loaded on last to match the drop off points on the route.
Twice daily deliveries were pulled along the supply chain to exactly match demand. This enabled the meatpacker to deliver exactly the daily requirements to the retailer which meant that the retailer’s shelves contained product available for their consumers.
The Challenges:
Compliance with Regulations;
Big batch manufacturing;
Transportation and Storage Logistics;
Packaging and Labeling;
Short Shelf Life; and
Consumer Preferences and Trends.
Implications
There is an empirical relationship between the customer service promise to the market, the replenishment lead time and the amount of stock that needs to be held to satisfy the customer service promise. The longer the manufacturing lead time, the higher the stock level required to satisfy the customer promise.
Results and Benefits
Proactive Order Processing;
Collaborative Procurement;
Proactive Inventory Management with accurate and real-time inventory data
Lower stock holding;
Space reduction;
Streamlined manufacturing processes;
Reduced replenishment lead times;
Optimized Transportation Network;
Increased productivity;
Increased profitability;
Reduced carbon footprint;
Increased performance against Customer Service Promise to 98%.
Traditional accounting methods simply tell us if an employee is paid for and cannot differentiate whether, or not, that employee is adding value to the business.
Activity-Based Costing (ABC) is a cost accounting method that allocates overhead costs based on the activities that drive those costs, rather than using traditional allocation methods like direct labor or machine hours. Here are some advantages of Activity-Based Costing over traditional accounting methods:
Accurate Cost Allocation: ABC provides more accurate cost allocation by directly linking costs to the specific activities that consume resources. This helps in better understanding of the true cost of producing a product or providing a service.
Improved Cost Management: ABC helps identify cost drivers and activities that contribute most to overhead costs, enabling management to focus on optimizing these activities to reduce costs and improve efficiency.
Better Decision-Making: With more accurate cost information provided by ABC, managers can make more informed decisions about pricing, product mix, resource allocation, and process improvements.
Enhanced Product Costing: Traditional costing methods may over-allocate or under-allocate overhead costs to products, leading to distorted product costs. ABC provides a more precise view of the costs associated with each product, helping companies make better pricing and production decisions.
Resource Utilization Insights: ABC helps identify underutilized resources and activities that may be driving unnecessary costs. This information can lead to better resource allocation and process optimization.
Improved Profitability Analysis: By accurately assigning costs to products, services, or customers, ABC provides a clearer picture of profitability at different levels of the organization, allowing businesses to focus on high-margin products or customers.
Enhanced Cost Transparency: ABC provides better visibility into the cost structure of the organization, helping stakeholders understand how costs are incurred and facilitating accountability for cost management.
Better Performance Evaluation: ABC can be used to evaluate the performance of different activities, departments, or products more accurately, leading to better performance measurement and incentive alignment.
While Activity-Based Costing offers many advantages over traditional costing methods, it is important to consider the implementation costs and complexity associated with ABC. Companies should assess their specific needs and circumstances to determine whether ABC is a suitable cost accounting method for their organization.
The Ask:
A prominent European retailer, boasting an annual revenue exceeding $20 billion, identified inefficiencies in its stores’ labor scheduling and budgeting processes. Traditionally, weekly staffing schedules and annual labor budgets were formulated based on revenue figures and managerial discretion across all stores. Seeking a more data-centric approach, the retailer initiated a pilot project to implement activity-based labor scheduling and budgeting in two stores over a four-month period.
The Approach
The project involved meticulous calculation of 65 activities and the development of an Excel-based prototype for a new labor-scheduling and budgeting tool. Subsequently, the prototype was tested in six diverse stores to ensure its applicability across the entire store network. Throughout the implementation, the retailer identified and swiftly integrated various best practices and process enhancements.
The Challenges:
The retailer had recently undertaken a successful LEAN retailing transformation and was concerned about implementing more change;
Stores perceived as well-managed due to their low labor costs were resistant to having more transparency potentially exposing sub-par store management practices;
Proximity for product transportation;
Swift retail store replenishment;
Warehouse capacity; and
Ability to stock shelves.
Results and Benefits
The adoption of the new staffing schedules and labor budgets resulted in:
Accurate Cost Allocation;
Enhanced Product Costing;
Improved Cost Management;
Better Decision-Making;
Improved Profitability Analysis;
Better Performance Evaluation;
Increased operational efficiency; and
Enhanced customer service.
These findings enabled the retailer to reassess and provide targeted training to its store managers, leading to improved operational performance and overall store management practices.
The Ask:
A global pharmaceutical company wanted to develop a QMS narrative document to outline the vision for a business-oriented quality management system, that actively supports the competitiveness of a modern pharmaceutical company in a rapidly changing healthcare environment and which would maintain regulatory compliance in all markets. explic8 was asked to develop solutions to the following questions:
How do we create a rapid transition from traditional pharma product development to innovative and integrated healthcare solutions with expertise, processes and governance structures which are ideally suited to support complex projects?
What are the implications for leadership, structure, governance, and team composition to build mutual understanding and effective execution?
Results and Benefits
The novel QMS framework that was developed is characterized by two key statements:
The QMS contains three axes – People, Process, and Programs and provides a clear and stable structure, and the realignment and optimization of Teams, Plans, and Roles within it creates a dynamic environment that is agile and governable;
The emphasis on Teams, Plans, and Roles allows the execution of programs of all degrees of complexity and innovation, each with its own ‘sweet spot’ in the framework, to supporting maximum agility without being at risk of leaving the protective boundaries of the QMS.
The stakeholders agreed that the framework is a viable Transformation Framework for a successful PD transformation, to achieve the client’s vision.
Challenges:
The company produces pharmaceutical products, delivery devices, diagnostic services and Patient Health Care devices;
Each of these is governed by different sets of regulations and ICH guidelines;
It is extremely difficult to embrace all of these governance structures into one QMS;
The senior stakeholders were in disagreement over the structure that the new QMS should take;
There were serious concerns about:
the governance of such a complex model;
whether innovative development projects could remain compliant within the QMS; and
The company’s capability to adapt to the change.
Implications
Risk of non-compliance
Threat to market position if the transformation is not successful.
Objectives
Develop a novel QMS approach that is agile, governable and supports the successful execution of innovative projects, whilst providing a stable framework that ensures the protective boundaries of a QMS would not be exceeded.
The Approach:
The project was proposed as a four-week effort by an explic8 senior consultant and a QMS consultant over a six-week period, with the following four phases:
Preparation phase: where explic8 understands the context of the QMS narrative effort and prepares 5-10 key stakeholders for their role in the project;
Interview phase: where explic8 engages said stakeholders to understand their requirements, expectations and potential concerns about the business-oriented quality management approach that should be reflected in the QMS narrative;
Analysis and consensus phase: where explic8 summarises and characterises the superset of requirements, expectations and concerns and drives consensus in the stakeholder group;
Closing phase: where explic8 redrafts the QMS narrative based on achieved consensus for adoption with final review, adoption by the stakeholder group and collective closeout meeting.
The Ask:
UK-based bespoke urban furniture manufacturer – Woodscape, approached explic8 for guidance and expertise on the implementation of the Material Resource Planning software (MRP) MRPeasy, as their current system was under utilised, resulting in the company remaining heavily reliant on complex spreadsheets requiring manual intervention to conduct their production planning and inventory control.
Results and Benefits
Centralised cloud-based software allowing access to production planning, inventory and procurement management
Visibility of manufacturing costs and customer order profits to enable enhanced strategic planning capabilities
Multiple complex planning documents made redundant
Increase in accuracy of stock control through implementation of shop floor reporting at the point of usage
Visualisation of production planning and Gantt chart of manufacturing operations
Challenges:
Over 70% of products were categorised as highly customised versions from a standard product catalogue or bespoke products based on customer specifications
Development of production planning data with the creation of bill of materials, routings and standard operating procedures
The incorporation of timber inventory control and processing requires satisfying regulatory requirements set by the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC)
Business process development required the MRPeasy software to be utilised by 40 employees and multiple business functions
Implications
Continued reliance on offline production planning documents would require investment in hardware infrastructure.
High levels of manual intervention required to ensure inventory levels were updated and managed.
Complex planning documents could not be accessed simultaneously.
Objectives
Implement the cloud-based MRP system MRPeasy with shop floor reporting and capacity capabilities.
Develop the methodology to deliver accurate production planning information requirements for products.
Increase the information available to Woodscape to allow for analysis of production costs through material and labour, capacity, profitability and inventory usage.
The Approach:
4-month project centred around consulting, analysing and developing processes to match system capabilities.
Analysis conducted into company processes to identify opportunities for improvement and to implement control and stability before the implementation of MRPeasy.
Mentoring internal problem-solving to develop solutions allowing for the successful implementation of the MRP software.
Strengthening interdepartmental relationships to share information and brainstorm solutions to challenges faced.